RUGBY
Vs FOOTBALL
(INTRODUCTION) Rugby finds its roots in football .One
day a British football player decided to take the ball because he was mad at
the referee into is hands and to bring it in the enemy goal. As this little anecdote
shows us rugby and soccer have some points in common, obviously both disciplines
are requiring a ball, a team play and the most important they need rules.
Although these two sports have a lot in common, they remain very different in
the way they are played, but depends on where you are in the world their
popularity vary a lot.
(PLAN
ANNOUCEMENT) In order to see the main differences my plan will fall into three parts: in the
first part we will broach to the way football and rugby are played ,their main characteristics, then
in a second time we will focus on how
the teams proceed to take points and the different rules that makes them take
even more points. As a third part we will lay the stress on the way playground/field
is divided and the way players have to adapt to these different parts. As a
final part I will end this essay comparing both sport’s popularity in some part
of the world
(1ST PART)Thus both game are not played the
same way, obviously rugby is far more violent than football, but I will
emphasize this first idea with 3 detailed ideas. The first one is the ball
.Indeed players are playing with a different one, soccer ball is circular
whereas rugby ball is oval. The second idea is focus on the number of player.
In a rugby team there are 15 players, on the other hand a football team count
11 players. The last idea of this first part is focused on what players in each
sport can use or cannot use. So in a rugby game players can use both hands and feet,
but they can only do a pass to the players behind him. Concerning football you
can only use your feet, except for the goalkeeper, who can use his hands.
(2nd PART)This last idea let me do a link with
the second part; the way points are counted and by extension the rules .In a rugby game there are several ways to make score, you can
score a try which means you took the ball behind the enemy try line ,this equals 5 points .You can also do a “drop”
you use the feet to kick the ball and
this one must go throw the pillars ,and
a drop is 3 points .In a football game
it’s much simpler, 1 goal equals 1 point and there is only one way to
get a point, kick the ball into the goal
.But some special rules can be applied
during the game and these rules can lead to make points. For rugby you can have
a penalty because the way players play is not appropriate with the rules a
penalty is working the same way like a drop, but it only brings 2 points. In a
football game you can have 2 situations, the free kick and the penalty, both
event is the result of an infringement of the rules and you still make 1 point
if you manage to put the ball in the goal.
(3rd.
PART) In order to have a strategy
players in both games need to adapt to the playground .So the way they are
placed are important each player has its
role ,defense player or front line
player. So the field in each sport are divided differently, for rugby the field
is divided in 6 (22meters, 50 meters try zone…) for football the field is
divided in two half and a zone dedicated to the goalkeeper. Some special rules
can be applied in some zone, like 22 meters or the zone dedicated to the
goalkeeper in which he is allowed to use his hands. As a consequence players
have to adapt themselves to the part on which they are playing. Of course the
strategies are not the same because the rules are also not the same, rugby
players can play the other players something that you cannot do in football.
(4th
PART) Rugby, and football are both
famous worldwide, but if we focus on some part of the world some countries has
made of the rugby, the, national sport. Countries like New Zealand, Australia,
or Argentina. So language is not determinant in the rugby’s popularity .On the other hand even if football comes from
England ,this one is very popular in Africa ,and South America. .We can explain
that phenomenon maybe because most of these countries were former colonies so
Europeans influence is still very important
Conclusion
as we have seen Rugby and Football are two different sport, in so far as they
don’t have the same rules, the same number of player and so on. But we’ve seen
that they are also popular not necessarily in the part of the world in which we
can expect. Rugby is for me a better sport because the value it vehicles fits
me more and also because it’s more about sport, than sponsor, like in football.